Castle Personal Training

Castle Personal Training is a Corstorphine, Edinburgh based company who specialise in weightloss/toning and Pre and Post Natal exercise.

Blog 14-10-13 Eat for what you want, not for what you have

Hi guys,

I work with a lot of medical professionals, from GPs to nurses and physios to dieticians, and even though most of them should know better there is still a gap between the “healthy eating” that they usually prescribe you and the “healthy eating” that Personal Trainers usually tell people to go for.

Personal Trainers almost immediately tell someone to “Go Low-carb” and that “the eat-well plate is non-sense or wrong”where as General Practioners and most doctors tell someone to go with the Eat-well plate and that “low-carb diets are dangerous”.

eatwell plate  Eat well plate for those of you unfamiliar with it.

Unsurprisingly they are both wrong. Whenever you hear someone say that a certain way of eating that has been around for years can just be discarded it is safe to assume they have no idea what they are talking about or are massively oversimplifying something.

I always tell people to “eat for what you want”. If you want to lose fat you will have to eat differently from someone who is trying to gain muscle. If you want to train like an athlete you will have to eat differently from someone who is not active. This does not mean “eat more” but it also means “eat different foods and have a different macro-split”.

macro-split example Just an example of a macro-split.

Let me try to break this down into a few simple examples;

1; You’re trying to lose fat, whilst preserving muscle-mass. This means that you will need to ensure you don’t take in too many carbohydrates. To explain this in a very simple way “Carbs are stored as fat if you eat too much of them”. Since the typical Western Diet is very carb heavy, and portion control is a skill most people lack, this means that there are now more obese people kicking about than there used to be. (An article on Carbohydrate metabolism can be found here) It also means you need to consume a maintenance amount of protein (approx 1gram of protein per Kg of musclemass)

“But I thought eating fatty foods made me fat!?”. No, this is wrong. Over consumption of calories will lead to you getting fat but the main contributor to the fat storage are carbs.

“So this means that everyone should go low-carb, all the time”. Only if you are trying to lose fat. A Low-carb diet is not meant to be a permanent life-style.

2; You’re trying to gain muscle-mass. This means that you will need to increase your protein intake. Protein builds muscle. Increase the protein intake and, combined with the right exercise, you’ll get bigger muscles. Anywhere between 1.5 and 2 grams of protein per Kg of musclemass is considered to be sufficient for most people.

So if I’m very muscular I should eat more protein”Yes you should but only because more of your bodyweight is muscle. To maintain your muscle-mass you should drop to eating approx 1gram of protein per Kg of bodyweight again. Only if you’re looking to gain muscle should you be eating 1.5-2grams per Kg of musclemass.

3; You’re perfectly happy maintaining your bodyfat % and weight and just want to eat healthy. This is by far the most interesting state and this is one that’s constantly being discussed. This is what the “eat-well” plate is based on. GPs and doctors generally only worry about homeostatis; IOW, they want to make sure you’re fit enough to do a desk-job and aren’t going to keel over from a heart-attack when you’re 40. Doctors, and most dieticians, don’t recommend to eat a certain way for those who train a lot. That’s what specialists, and well-trained and certified Personal Trainers, do.

I like a 30% carb, 40% protein, 30% fats split (healthy fats obviously) but you can move these figures about a bit depending on what suits you.

So say you have the following situation;

A 37 year old man walks into the gym and states that he wants to build up some muscle. This now means he needs to start taking on board 1.5-2g of protein per Kg of muscle mass and increase his calorie intake (You can’t build musclemass properly if you’re in a calorie deficit)

Say he’s a very smart guy and gets fast results (IOW, he trains with Castle) and he then decides to lose a bit of fat but maintain his musclemass as he’s happy with that. This now means he needs to drop his protein intake to approx 1gram of protein per Kg of musclemass AND he needs to drop his carbohydrate intake.

Finally he has achieved his results and is delighted with his progress and body (Like everyone training with us is 😉 ). He now needs to maintain at 1g of protein per Kg and needs to go up to a maintenance level of carbohydrates.

You can see from the above that he has needed to change his diet 3x already. If he decides he wants to train for endurance events or power events he will need to change his diet, and training again.

veggies_why_grocery_bags1 Healthy but not always right.

There is no “one magical way” to eat for the rest of your life. We all know that when you get older your metabolism changes dramatically.

This is why we at Castle work with PERSONALISED nutrition plans and not the generic junk you get from other Personal Trainers. You eat for what you want, not for what you have if you need help with this, get in touch.

Take care,

Your friend.


4 comments on “Blog 14-10-13 Eat for what you want, not for what you have

  1. Hi! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to
    give a quick shout out and say I truly enjoy reading through your blog posts.
    Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that
    deal with the same subjects? Thank you so much!

  2. Pingback: 5 questions you wanted to ask….and did. | Castle Personal Training

  3. Pingback: Free foods on Weightwatchers and Slimmingworld? | Castle Personal Training

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: